A stone family home with a landscaped front yard and shade trees
Home / About Us

Meet Tina Gregory. Your hometown Farmers agent in Sullivan.

We're a Farmers Insurance agency with more than one door. Farmers comes first, and through Kraft Lake we can quote other companies when Farmers isn't the best fit. Either way, we explain your coverage and let you pick what works for you.

52
Client Reviews
Farmers
+ Kraft Lake Options
Sullivan
Local Office
4
Hometown Team
Mon–Fri
9 AM–5 PM Central
The Quick Answer

Tina Gregory Agency (Tina Gregory Insurance Agency LLC) is a Farmers Insurance agency in Sullivan, Missouri, at 878 Dunsford Dr. The agency's owner is Tina Gregory, who leads a hometown team of four.

Farmers is the primary company. When Farmers isn't the best fit, the office can also quote other companies, such as Progressive and Liberty Mutual, through Kraft Lake Insurance Agency, a Farmers-owned agency that's appointed only with non-Farmers companies. Foremost and Bristol West are part of the Farmers family. Coverage includes auto, home, condo, renters, landlord, flood, umbrella, motorcycle, RV and boat, life and business insurance. Not every product or company is available in every situation.

The team: Tina Gregory (Owner & Agent), Matthew Tolliver (Insurance Agent, born and raised in Sullivan), Kathleen Orick (Insurance Agent, a Sullivan resident for 10 years and a local teacher) and Maggie Gregory (Office Coordinator). The agency has 52 client reviews across Google and its Farmers page and serves Sullivan and nearby towns, including Stanton, Bourbon, St. Clair, Leslie, Gerald, Cuba, Union, Steelville, Owensville and Washington.

"We actually explain the coverages to you and let you pick what works for you." Quotes are free. Call (573) 358-4513, Monday to Friday, 9:00 AM to 5:00 PM Central.

The owner
Tina Gregory · Owner & Agent
The agency
Farmers first · more options via Kraft Lake
The proof
52 client reviews · Google & Farmers
Office
878 Dunsford Dr · Sullivan, MO
Talk to the team
(573) 358-4513

One Sullivan office. More than one door.

↓ start here ↓
Welcome to Tina Gregory Agency

Protecting what matters most. Family, home and everything you've worked hard for.

Hi, I'm Tina Gregory, owner of Tina Gregory Agency in Sullivan, Missouri!

Family has always been my number one priority. In fact, it's what brought me to the Sullivan area. I made the decision to move here so our whole family could be back together, and I couldn't be happier to call this community home.

That same love for family is what drives my passion for helping others protect theirs. I know how much the people we love, the homes we've built, and the things we've worked hard for mean to us. My goal is to help other families understand how to protect those things, so they can have confidence in the coverage they've chosen.

At Tina Gregory Agency, we believe insurance should be personal, not just another transaction. When you walk through our doors or give us a call, you're not just a policy number. You're a neighbor, and we want you to feel like you're talking with someone who genuinely cares.

One thing I feel strongly about is making sure our customers actually understand their insurance. Too often, people purchase policies without really knowing what is covered until something happens. We want to change that.

We take the time to explain your coverages, answer your questions, and let you decide what works best for your family and your budget. No pressure, no confusing insurance talk, just honest conversations and guidance you can trust.

While Farmers Insurance is our primary company, including Bristol West and Foremost, we also have access to additional insurance companies, including Progressive and Liberty Mutual, through Kraft Lake Insurance Agency. This allows us to explore additional options when Farmers may not be the right fit.

From auto and home insurance to life, business, flood, umbrella and recreational vehicle coverage, we're here to help you protect the things that matter most.

Family is my why. Tina Gregory · Owner & Agent, Tina Gregory Agency
The owner

Tina Gregory: family is her why

"I believe in building lasting relationships, treating people with kindness, and helping every customer the same way I would want someone to help my own family." Read Tina's story.

The agent

Matthew Tolliver, born and raised in Sullivan

Born and raised in Sullivan, Matthew knows this community firsthand and enjoys helping his neighbors find coverage that fits their needs. Read Matthew's story.

The agent and teacher

Kathleen Orick brings a teacher's patience

A Sullivan resident for 10 years and a local teacher, Kathleen brings a genuine passion for helping people and making a difference in our community. Read Kathleen's story.

Behind the scenes

Maggie Gregory keeps the office running

Maggie helps keep our office running smoothly and makes sure everyone who contacts our agency feels welcomed and appreciated. Read Maggie's story.

Today

A team of four in Sullivan

One office, four people, and 52 client reviews across Google and our Farmers page. We serve Sullivan and nearby towns with Farmers first and more options through Kraft Lake. Meet Tina and her team below.

The Tina Gregory Agency team in the Sullivan office: Kathleen Orick and Matthew Tolliver standing, Tina Gregory and Maggie Gregory seated
Left to right: Kathleen Orick, Tina Gregory, Maggie Gregory and Matthew Tolliver in the Sullivan office.
Meet the agency owner

Tina Gregory. Owner & Agent, Tina Gregory Agency.

Family has always been Tina's number one priority. It's what brought her to the Sullivan area: she moved here so her whole family could be back together, and she couldn't be happier to call this community home.

That same love for family drives her passion for helping others protect theirs. Tina believes insurance should be personal, not just another transaction. At her office at 878 Dunsford Dr in Sullivan, you're not a policy number. You're a neighbor.

She feels strongly that customers should actually understand their insurance. In her words: "We actually explain the coverages to you and let you pick what works for you." No pressure, no confusing insurance talk.

Tina's agency is Farmers first, including Bristol West and Foremost. When Farmers isn't the right fit, the office can also quote companies such as Progressive and Liberty Mutual through Kraft Lake Insurance Agency.

Tina Gregory, owner of Tina Gregory Agency, a Farmers Insurance agency in Sullivan, Missouri
Tina GregoryOwner & Agent · Tina Gregory Agency
FarmersInsurance agency in Sullivan, MO
Kraft LakeMore options when Farmers isn't the fit
4People on her hometown team
52Client reviews on Google & Farmers

Meet Tina and her team. Four people, one Sullivan office.

When you call, you'll talk with this team: the people who quote your coverage, explain your options and are still here when your needs change. See the full team page.

Tina Gregory, Owner and Agent at Tina Gregory Agency in Sullivan, Missouri
Tina Gregory
Owner & Agent

Family is my why. I believe in building lasting relationships, treating people with kindness, and helping every customer the same way I would want someone to help my own family.

Read Tina's story →
Matthew Tolliver, Insurance Agent at Tina Gregory Agency in Sullivan, Missouri
Matthew Tolliver
Insurance Agent

Born and raised in Sullivan, Matthew knows this community firsthand and enjoys helping his neighbors find coverage that fits their needs.

Read Matthew's story →
Kathleen Orick, Insurance Agent at Tina Gregory Agency in Sullivan, Missouri
Kathleen Orick
Insurance Agent

A Sullivan resident for 10 years and a local teacher, Kathleen brings a genuine passion for helping people and making a difference in our community.

Read Kathleen's story →
Maggie Gregory, Office Coordinator at Tina Gregory Agency in Sullivan, Missouri
Maggie Gregory
Office Coordinator

Maggie helps keep our office running smoothly and makes sure everyone who contacts our agency feels welcomed and appreciated.

Read Maggie's story →
Farmers + Kraft Lake

Farmers first. More doors when you need them.

Tina Gregory Agency is a Farmers Insurance agency, and Farmers is where we start. The Farmers family also includes Foremost and Bristol West, which are Farmers Insurance Group companies. Between them, that covers a lot of ground: auto, home, condo, renters, landlord, flood, umbrella, motorcycle, RV and boat, life and business insurance.

When Farmers isn't the best fit, we have more doors. Through Kraft Lake Insurance Agency, a Farmers-owned agency that's appointed only with non-Farmers companies, we can also quote outside companies such as Progressive, Liberty Mutual and others. Not every product or company is available in every situation, and we'll tell you plainly what is.

Built for homeowners with more than one car

A lot of our clients own a home and have a couple of vehicles in the driveway. Keeping home and auto together means one number to call and one team that knows your whole picture, and bundling may lower your price. Farmers also offers discounts for certain occupations, like educators, first responders and nurses, and you may qualify. Discounts and eligibility vary and aren't available in every situation.

Who you're working with. Because "trust us" isn't a credential.

Insurance runs on trust, so here's what you'd want to know before handing someone your auto, home, and family's coverage.

The agency
Farmers

Farmers Insurance Agency

Tina Gregory Agency (Tina Gregory Insurance Agency LLC) is a Farmers Insurance agency at 878 Dunsford Dr in Sullivan. See our Farmers profile.

More options
Kraft Lake

More Doors Through Kraft Lake

When Farmers isn't the best fit, we can quote companies like Progressive and Liberty Mutual through Kraft Lake Insurance Agency, a Farmers-owned agency.

Local roots
Sullivan

Sullivan Born-and-Raised Agent

Matthew Tolliver, our Insurance Agent, was born and raised in Sullivan and has strong roots and relationships in the area. Meet Matthew.

Reviews
52

Client Reviews

52 reviews from clients across Google and our Farmers page. Read them on Google.

License
Missouri

Licensed in Missouri

We're licensed to sell insurance in Missouri. You can look up any Missouri agent's license through the Missouri Department of Commerce and Insurance.

The team
4

A Team of Four

Tina, Matthew, Kathleen and Maggie, all in one Sullivan office. When you call, you talk to someone who knows the area. Meet the team.

How we work. Five habits that don't change.

1

We explain, you choose

You'll understand what you're buying before you buy it. That includes what Missouri's 25/50/25 auto liability minimums do and don't cover, why uninsured motorist coverage is required here, what optional underinsured motorist and medical payments coverage add, and how a percentage wind and hail deductible works if your home policy has one.

2

Farmers first, more doors when needed

We start with Farmers. When it isn't the best fit, we can also quote other companies through Kraft Lake and lay out the trade-offs side by side. Call (573) 358-4513 to see your options.

3

Bundle where it helps

Homeowners with more than one car are who we help most. Bundling home and auto may lower your price, and we'll check whether you may qualify for other discounts. If bundling doesn't help in your case, we'll say so.

4

A real person answers

You'll reach Tina, Matthew, Kathleen or Maggie, not a call center. One office, one phone number, Monday through Friday, 9:00 AM to 5:00 PM Central. Meet the team.

5

Built for Sullivan and nearby towns

We're on Dunsford Dr in Sullivan, close to I-44 and MO-185, and we help families in Stanton, Bourbon, St. Clair, Leslie, Gerald, Cuba, Union, Steelville, Owensville, Washington and across Franklin and Crawford counties. See our Sullivan office.

Local people. Real conversations. Coverage you understand.

Looking for a new policy, wondering if you have enough coverage, or just want someone to explain your options? Stop by and meet us. We'd love the opportunity to get to know you and your family!

Questions people ask about Tina Gregory Agency.

Is Tina Gregory Agency only Farmers? +

No. We're a Farmers Insurance agency, and Farmers comes first. The Farmers family also includes Foremost and Bristol West.

When Farmers isn't the best fit, we can also quote other companies, such as Progressive and Liberty Mutual, through Kraft Lake Insurance Agency, a Farmers-owned agency that's appointed only with non-Farmers companies. Not every product or company is available in every situation.

Where is your office? +

We're at 878 Dunsford Dr, Sullivan, MO 63080. We help clients in Sullivan and nearby towns, including Stanton, Bourbon, St. Clair, Leslie, Gerald, Cuba, Union, Steelville, Owensville and Washington.

We're licensed in Missouri. See our Sullivan office page for directions.

What are your hours? +

Monday through Friday, 9:00 AM to 5:00 PM Central. We're closed Saturday and Sunday.

You can call (573) 358-4513 during business hours or start a free quote online anytime.

Who will I work with when I call? +

Someone on our team of four: Tina Gregory, our Owner and Agent; Matthew Tolliver and Kathleen Orick, our Insurance Agents; or Maggie Gregory, our Office Coordinator.

There's no call center and no phone tree. Meet the team.

Do you offer discounts for certain occupations? +

You may qualify. Farmers offers occupation-based discounts for professions such as educators, first responders (firefighters and law enforcement), military, nurses and physicians, engineers, scientists, accountants, architects, lawyers and judges, librarians, veterinarians, aviators and dentists.

Eligibility and discount amounts vary and aren't available in every situation. Bundling home and auto may also lower your price. Ask us what applies to you.

Something we didn't cover? Call (573) 358-4513 or start a free quote.

Find us elsewhere. Same team, one Sullivan office.

Every link below is ours. Stop by 878 Dunsford Dr, message us, or pick up the phone.

Explore the coverage.

Whichever door you came for,
it opens with one call.

A new policy, a second opinion on what you have, or both. We'll explain your options in plain English and let you pick what works for you. Zero pressure.