Meet Tina and her team. Four neighbors, one Sullivan office.
When you call Tina Gregory Agency, these are the people you're talking to. Tap anyone in the photo to meet them.
Tina GregoryOwner & Agent
Matthew TolliverInsurance Agent
Kathleen OrickInsurance Agent
Maggie GregoryOffice Coordinator
Left to right: Kathleen, Tina, Maggie and Matthew.
Say hi. Everyone has a story.

Family is her why. She explains your coverage, then lets you choose.
Meet Tina →- Owner
- Family is my why
- We explain. You choose.

Born and raised in Sullivan. Loves getting to know people, and talking sports.
Meet Matthew →- Sullivan born & raised
- Sports nut
- Dad-to-be

A Sullivan resident for 10 years and a local teacher, with a genuine passion for helping people.
Meet Kathleen →- Insurance agent
- 10 years in Sullivan
- Teacher

Keeps the office organized and running, and keeps Matthew in line.
Meet Maggie →- Behind the scenes
- Keeps Matthew in line
- Mom-to-be
How we can help. One call, the right person.
Start a quote online or call. Tina or Matthew will explain your options and let you pick what works.
QuestionsNot sure what you're covered for?Call (573) 358-4513. We'll walk through your policy in plain English.
Already a clientPay a bill or report a claimCompany phone numbers and links in one place, or call the office and we'll help.
Ready to meet us?
878 Dunsford Dr, Sullivan.
Monday to Friday, 9 AM to 5 PM Central. Farmers first, more options when you need them, and a team that explains everything.